China is far too large for a collapse of the Soviet Union however, it’s also on unstable foundations
As its growth slows, China’s prospects are still being determined. We should be thankful that the changes aren’t sudden,
The Chinese economy is experiencing an upswing. Its growth is lagging, and its housing bubble has wholly ruptured. The unemployment rate is increasing.
What do you suggest? Every country experiences difficult times where past excesses get caught up to it. Then the cycle of economics turns, and the recovery starts. China is the second-largest economy and has grown staggeringly over the last four decades. China plays a vital role in the world economy and has invested heavily in modern manufacturing and Artificial Intelligence. It has its challenges. However, it can overcome them reasonably unscathed.
Some countries never recover. It was the case with Russia. The Soviet Union was a command economy rapidly falling apart at the end of the 80s. In retrospect, it’s obvious why the final crisis was inevitable. However, it wasn’t like that at the time. The Kremlin sent SS20 missiles across Eastern Europe just a few years before.
Here’s a different viewpoint. China’s economic miracle has ended. What’s transpired over the last week – the deterioration of China’s currency, the drop in the prices, and the financial crisis that is evident in the residential housing market are all indications of a more severe problem that will force the communist party into power to make structural changes in the economy that require the reduction in the rigidity of its political control. China’s president, Xi Jinping, is a self-described strongman who isn’t willing to give up any of his rights to the rule of law and democratic principles. Soon, China will go the route and become like the Soviet Union.
This may sound far-fetched. It is true that the Soviet Union was a far smaller economy than China and was less integrated into world supply chains. China is vital to the global economy like the Soviet Union never did.
As Dhaval Joshi from BCA Research points out, China has contributed 41 per cent of global growth over the last ten years, more than twice the contribution of 22% from the US and surpassing the donation of 9% by the eurozone.
“Put another approach that of the 2.6 per cent real growth rate of the global economy over the past ten years, China has generated 1.1 percentage points, whereas the US and the eurozone have only produced 0.6 percentage points, and 0.2 points, respectively.”
China is an enormous chunk of growth globally because it grew at an average of 8-9% per year. However, its growth rate is only half of that, which means around 0.5 points will reduce its share of global growth. In addition, the growth rate will likely decrease further in the coming years. Some economists believe its growth rate will be close to 2 per cent by the end of the decade, comparable to the US.
These predictions are highly premature. Beijing’s objective is more moderate but balanced and sustainable growth because policymakers must refrain from cutting interest rates, increasing state spending, or bailing out an overextended property market in the event of trouble. The reason to believe in China is that the model of limited economic freedom paired with the repression of political leaders has been working for decades, starting with the Deng reforms in the 1970s and will be effective in the near future, assuming some adjustment.
When he took power in the Soviet Union in 1985, Mikhail Gorbachev had a twin-tracked approach: “glasnost” represented the desire for openness and transparency, and “perestroika” was the reorganization of the economy to end an extended period of stagnation. The collapse of the Soviet Union was a result of the more significant progress made with glasnost than perestroika. The Chinese leadership took lessons from this. They were able to accelerate the process of reforms but were less keen on the glasnost.
So far, putting the economy over democracy has been a success for China. Still, despite Beijing’s insistence by policymakers that everything will continue to be in order, there is evidence to suggest that those who are sceptical of China’s economic outlook are not right. The predicted strong recovery after removing the lockdown on pandemic restrictions has yet to materialize. China’s economy had already shown indicators of slowing before the introduction of Covid-19.
In the Foreign Affairs magazine, Adam Posen, president of the Petersen Institute for International Economics, stated that China was afflicted by “economic lengthy Covid” in the latter half of last decade.
Since 2015, bank deposits have been part of China’s GDP, which has increased by 50 per cent. Consumption of durable goods by the private sector is down by about 1/3 compared to early 2015. It continues to fall after the economy reopens instead of increasing due to the accumulated demand. Private investment has decreased by two-thirds since the start of the year 2015, which includes a decrease of 25 per cent decrease since the outbreak began.
“Those tendencies reflect people’s long-term economic choices over time, which suggest that, in China, businesses and individuals are becoming more concerned about being denied access to assets and tend to prioritize cash flow in the short term over investment,” Posen says. The fears, he says, are exacerbated by the force and constant nature of China’s clampdown.
China was facing severe issues before Covid. It was an ageing population, and, despite forty years of rapid growth, it was still a middle-income nation. Its growth rate was artificially inflated due to a lack of public investment and the granting of subsidies to non-economic businesses that could have dissolved.
In the end, an examination of the globe suggests that authoritarian regimes can remain in the power they enjoy even when the economy isn’t growing and inflation is high. The change in China is likely to occur, but if it does, it may be gradual rather than swift, and if it is, we should be thankful. The abrupt collapse of the Soviet Union was followed by the world experiencing a boom. The sudden fall of China will result in a global slump.